The claim:
[i][The Horst wave-theremin is][/i] "a Midi Theremin alternative that is far superior to the Moog Ethervox Theremin "
is still there.. but, actually, I now view this claim as more laughable than offensive
The Ether-Vox is a superbly crafted musical instrument, with exceptional linearity (Horst states about his 'theremin': "The Theremin's pitch range is linearised and fully adjustable for each instrument setting" - Which might mean almost anything.. it does not state that the pitch field is linear - but it does imply this, however the fact that the demo's never show any tune or recognisable scales being played points to the likelyhood that linearity is not good).
The Ether-Vox is a great Theremin,and probably the best MIDI outputting gestural controller ever built.. And The Ether-Vox has both Pitch and Volume antennas (as ALL REAL THEREMINS MUST HAVE) and outputs Pitch and Volume data from its comprehensive MIDI control unit (which also features MIDI Input, an essential requirement if replaying of performances via the Theremin is required, and one of the many things lacking in the Horst box). I am no fan of MIDI Theremins generally - But there is NO comparison between the Horst box and the Ether-Vox.. It is like comparing a pedal trycycle to a Rolls Royce, and saying that the trycycle is "far superior".
Horst, in my opinion, by making this claim, is claiming way too much - to the point where he could be seen as delusional!
Last time I commented on a Horst "theremin" I became involved in a "discussion" with an 'advocate' of this "theremin" who I believe was Horst or a representitive of Horst.. I will not engage in "debate" about this Theremin - There is no ambiguity this time..
< I have removed the old argument I repeated here>
This discussion degenerated to personal shit-hurling (from both sides) and I dont wish to go there again.. There is nothing more to discuss!
I do not dispute the fact that there may be a place in the market for the Horst box, it has some pleasant sounds and could suit some musical applications.. BUT as a Theremin, it cannot compete with, and is GREATLY INFERIOR to EVERY Theremin (Ether-Wave, Jaycar, Burns and obviously the Ether-Vox) which the Horst site
The new Horst "wave-theremin" can be seen at: http://www.wave-theremin.com/
I feel there is a really sad side to all the above.. Horst is obviously an extremely skilled electronics engineer, and the sounds his instruments produce are good.. He has spent 2 years developing this instrument, but it seems that he has not consulted any person who really plays a Theremin or has any idea about what is really needed in this market.
Seeing what he has done in 2 years makes me believe that he could have developed a great Theremin - If only he had consulted Theremin players and learned what a Theremin is..[i] < And if he had refrained from making u