Surely if you have good relative pitch and are given a starting note then you'll be fine. I do that when singing solo- and when I finish I'm normally on the right note (give or take a flattened semitone).
What type of ear skills do I need: absolute pitch or relative pitch?
Posted: 3/8/2005 11:01:13 PM
With regard to stringed instruments (I play the double bass a little), it's kinda absolute when hitting an initial note, then relative after that, although alot of the time you're not necessarily playing by ear - there are set fingerings on that you learn that get you pretty on the mark.
Some players put a dot marker on the fretboard so that initial notes are found more easily.
Tactile feedback from the strings and board also give you an indication of where you are.
Learning double bass for me was pretty easy, coming from an electric bass and guitar background, because there is a set method that's kinda Lego-like...methinks learning the theremin is gonna be a whole new ball game!
Some players put a dot marker on the fretboard so that initial notes are found more easily.
Tactile feedback from the strings and board also give you an indication of where you are.
Learning double bass for me was pretty easy, coming from an electric bass and guitar background, because there is a set method that's kinda Lego-like...methinks learning the theremin is gonna be a whole new ball game!
Posted: 3/25/2005 7:43:51 AM
You need relative pitch. Perfict pitch can actualy be a detrament in the real word.
Do you know why oboes are used as a pitch refrence in an orchastra?
Because they are the hardest to get properly in tune. I am gnu to the Theremin (how gnu ... waiting for my kit to arrive today) but I have played bassoon in many orchastras - even to the point of getting paid to do it for a few years - so I know of what I speak.
BTY: Unless groups are playing with an instrament with true fixed pitch - like an organ or piano - they tend towards some version of pure/Ptolemic/Pythagorean intervals.
Also it should be know that pitch can drift with the group. For example most Shaped Note singers in the south tend to sing about 1/2 step flat from the written music.
So to answer your question. I think in the real world try for good relative pitch.
Do you know why oboes are used as a pitch refrence in an orchastra?
Because they are the hardest to get properly in tune. I am gnu to the Theremin (how gnu ... waiting for my kit to arrive today) but I have played bassoon in many orchastras - even to the point of getting paid to do it for a few years - so I know of what I speak.
BTY: Unless groups are playing with an instrament with true fixed pitch - like an organ or piano - they tend towards some version of pure/Ptolemic/Pythagorean intervals.
Also it should be know that pitch can drift with the group. For example most Shaped Note singers in the south tend to sing about 1/2 step flat from the written music.
So to answer your question. I think in the real world try for good relative pitch.
You must be logged in to post a reply. Please log in or register for a new account.