I am moving my comments from the Melodia thread
http://www.thereminworld.com/Forums/T/28684/moog-melodia?Page=2
(damn editor isnt allowing me to insert the link where I want it)
to here, as these are not anything to do with the Melodia, but are covered by "Everything else" ;-)
"Amen Fred that's why I keep it illusive, whether you’re a performer or designer there “is” something special about keeping a mystery shrouding ones theremin work, if it is playful & productive." - Christopher.
I do not try to keep anything "illusive" or "shrouded in mystery" - And the few times that I have been forced to keep a "trade" or other secret I have found this extremely disconcerting and uncomfortable - "out of character" if you like - just not "me".
One big advantage of disclosing everything you discover, is that (provided others share your attitude) one gets critical evaluation of ones hypotheses, which can eliminate or find fault with your hypothesis far faster - therebye saving you a lot of time /effort by stopping you going too far with a naff idea..
My most wonderful moments of synergy was when I was working with a team exploring a new science - Biophysical Chemistry - We had the buzz of coming up with designs for new equipment to do new experiments - everything from producing one molicule thick films of lipids to rotating protien molicules using lazer bombardment.. Everyone needed to communicate with other engineers or doctors etc (a load of nerds in lab coats ;-) clearly about their dicipline so that others of a different dicipline could colaborate.
If there had been anything "illusive" or "shrouded in mystery" between us, progress would have been impossible - it was often extremely difficult, even with everyone communicating as best they could, to understand each others ideas - biologist, chemists, physicists, mechanical engineers, and me on electronics - all had to share our specialist knowledge to come up with practical ways to implement experiments.
When I said "there’s something sad about answering a question completely" This is not a big issue- there are plenty of questions! IMO, even if we did eventually get a "theory of everything" (and I doubt that we will) there will still be enough unknowns within such a grand theory to keep us busy for millenia - And even if we progress to the level where these unknowns are easily resolved, there is still an infinite abundance of invention and application to explore -
And at a personal level, the fact that Lev invented the theremin in the 1930's does not remove the buzz one gets from learning the art and constructing your own theremin, even if its been done thousands of times before by others.. Every individual has their own journey of discovery - it is as new for them and carries (almost) the same rewards as it did for the pioneers.
And only a few are lucky enough to truly "discover or "invent" something entirely new - realistically these days, the best one can hope for is to participate in this process - and the best way to do this, IMO, is to share ones thoughts openly with others .. They may be the ones who make the "breakthrough" but at least you are part of the process, whether you live to see it or not. The question I asked earlier on this thread regarding "where does the energy go" is this kind of thing - it may be a baloney question - but it may not be - it may lead to some thinking which leads to something, and it may not...
In the end, perhaps its all just about giving some "meaning" to life - its all a game really - but one doesnt usually walk away from a game if one is enjoying it..
Fred.
Oh well - in the process of moving my most off-topic posting, I managed to delete it.. LOL
"Note: Angel of Death is what the angel was called at Passover, assisting Moses in freeing his people. As the wind blew there was a terrifying sound! I am disappointed when the illusions of some bands glorify the demonic. Brian Welch known as Head in the band Korn recognized this and walked away to form a new band, still hard rock driven by a great guitarist." - Christopher
I disagree with the idea that the story of the "angel of death" has any truth in it - and I disagree with the notion that "demonic" is a word which has any specifically religous meaning - what is "demonic" to some is seen as "angelic" to others IMO. To me, "demonic" is anything which promotes hatred or bigotry or racism.. I dislike bands who are "demonic" in this sense - whether they be "satan worshipers" or "christian fundamentalists" or "islamists" or whatever.
To me, an "angel" who causes people not protected by some "secret mark" over their door, to be struck down - regardless of their personal "goodness" or "badness" - Who causes indescriminate suffering to innocent individuals - well - thats about as "demonic" as one can get.
Add to this the "fact" that this "angel" is working for an "all knowing" god, and the "secret mark" seems a bit redundant - this "god" should know who are "his people" without the need for blood - this god should be capable of instructing his angel to inflict his curse only on those who individually "deserve" it - But thats not the nature of this "god" is it ? This is a "god" who, when the Pharoh wanted to let the Hebrews leave, "hardened the heart of the Pharoh" so that he wouldnt let them leave - this then gave "god" an excuse to inflict the Egyptians with the plagues.
I always hated teachers who punished a whole class for the actions of a few individuals.. And I hate any "god" who behaves in this way - hate with a passion!
To me, the whole story reeks of "unrightiousness", injustice and immorality - "god" in this story is a vile, sadistic, dishonest, cruel, sick psychopath - his "angel of death" is a "demon", and the "devil" is, by comparison, quite benign!